6 Signs Your Patient Is at Risk for Treatment-Resistant Depression - Psychiatricanswers

Psychiatric Answers
The Place to Get Answers About Mental Health
Go to content

Main menu:

Opinions, Commentaries and Publications

6 Signs Your Patient Is at Risk for Treatment-Resistant Depression.

By Alessandro Serretti, MD, PhD and Chiara Fabbri, MD
August 29, 2017


Comment:

This is a very-well written article but its premise, to me it is a fallacy. I have never encounter one case of so-called TRD that does not respond to a trial with a mood stabilizer.
If we believe that depression is associated with certain receptors in the brain, it should not be a matter of discussion that when you have targeted all of them the mood should improve. On the other hand, almost 100% of patients that have come to me with “depression and anxiety” have a mood disorder and agitation, which is worsened using SSRIs (check the “ARAD” syndrome described by Dr. Ronald Pies).
This paper’s case vignette reminded me of a study published by a group in Canada that reported (in 2000) improvement of Conduct Disorder and Oppositional-Defiant Disorder with risperidone. Like in this case, patients improved because risperidone can help to balance the mood in patients with sub-threshold cases of bipolar spectrum disorder.
If clinicians continue to believe that “bipolar” is just what Kraepelin described (hundreds of years ago) we will keep seeing “Treatment-Resistant Depression”. Also, responsible for the failure to capture mild cases of the bipolar spectrum is the unjustifiable neglect of entering the family history into the equation to formulate a diagnosis. In gathering family history, we must be a “detective” and decline to be satisfied with “nobody in family has mental illness”. Many people use alcohol and cannabis (or worst yet, opioids) to control a “racing mind”, impulsivity or explosive temper.
Finally, one major obstacle in making a proper diagnosis of a bipolar spectrum disorder is the fear of “giving a bad label”, that some clinicians have. And this is puzzling to me because I see doctors telling the mother of a young child “your son has a malignant brain cancer” or to the wife of a man in his 40s, “your husband has a Stage-4 pancreatic cancer” while doctors and others in the mental health field hesitate to talk about a treatable illness.

Dr. Manuel Mota-Castillo
Chief of Psychiatry and Training Director at
Burrell College of Osteopathic Medicine (BCOM) and
Director of Behavioral Health Services at
Memorial Medical Center, both in Las Cruces, NM

Copyright Psychiatric Answers © 2017
Back to content | Back to main menu